
By Brian Darr
Press Play Contributor
How was your weekend? Here’s hoping it wasn’t a hundredth as disastrous as Labor Day weekend was for Roscoe Arbuckle or Virginia Rappe exactly ninety years ago.
It was on Labor Day weekend in 1921, in the midst of Prohibition, that screen comedian Arbuckle found himself at a party on the 12th floor of the St. Francis Hotel in downtown San Francisco. By the end of the weekend, much alcohol had been consumed, a 30-year-old actress (Rappe) had died, and the rotund 34-year-old star (known to his fans as “Fatty,” a nickname he abhorred in his private life) was charged with manslaughter. His career was instantly in ruins.
Roscoe Arbuckle was a singer, dancer, acrobat and clown who had landed in Hollywood in 1913 and joined Mack Sennet’s Keystone troupe, where he soon rose to great fame playing opposite comedienne Mabel Normand in a very successful string of two-reel short films. Legend has it that fellow Keystoner Charlie Chaplin developed the baggy-clothed attire of his “Little Tramp” character after trying on one of Arbuckle’s plus-sized outfits. Later, working for Joe Schenck, Arbuckle gave the great Buster Keaton his start in pictures, casting and directing him as co-conspirator in a set of comedies beginning with The Butcher Boy (1917).
By the early 1920s, Arbuckle was, with Charlie Chaplin, one of the top two comedy stars in motion pictures. He made the jump to feature-length films with 1920’s The Round-Up, and made several more features for Paramount before his career was cut short. In the wake of scandal, Arbuckle’s films were withdrawn from circulation. Few of the films he made in the first 8 months of 1921 are even known to survive today, some of which never screened commercially in the United States. This is what made a recent screening of Leap Year at the Niles Essanay Silent Film Museum such a notable event.
Niles nestles against the hills of Fremont, California, 30 miles east of San Francisco and 350 miles north of Los Angeles. Filled with antique shops and humble residences, it’s a town steeped in motion picture history. The first cowboy movie star, G.A. “Bronco Billy” Anderson, and Charlie Chaplin were among those who encamped there to shoot pictures in the mid-1910s, before Hollywood became the go-to site for filmmaking in California.
Now, nearly a hundred years later, the Niles Essanay Silent Film Museum keeps the past alive with weekly Saturday evening screenings of silent movies backed by live musical accompaniments. It’s one of the few public venues where one can regularly see 16 mm and 35 mm prints of all kinds of American and occasionally European silents. Well-known classics (Theda Bara’s star-making A Fool There Was plays in late October, as well as The Man Who Laughs starring Conrad Veidt, whose character inspired Bob Kane’s design for The Joker) rub elbows with little-seen films with fewer than five IMDB votes (1923’s Let’s Go, featuring legendary stuntman Richard Talmadge, screens October 8th). Special attention is given to short subjects, which precede every feature shown (Arbuckle’s own brilliant two-reeler Fatty and Mabel Adrift plays before a Mary Pickford film on September 24th) and get a monthly showcase of their own. Niles is a grand place to see the silent-era examples of film artistry that continue to influence moviemaking to this day and to discover all-but-forgotten gems.
Leap Year, however, is neither an established classic nor a forgotten film. Rarely screened, it’s remembered as one of the ultimately shelved features Arbuckle completed before his fateful Labor Day. The industry was worried about how seeing their favorite star in a romantic comedy, filled with screwball twists and turns, might affect audiences while details of his scandal, as reported by newspapers, were fresh in mind.

The details reported were damning. Arbuckle was accused of raping Rappe and consequently killing her with his girth. No evidence of rape was found, the charge was reduced from murder to manslaughter, and after two hung juries a third wrote a letter of apology to Arbuckle above and beyond their acquittal. Nonetheless, the daily headlines of the case had already sold huge quantities of newspapers. (Buster Keaton later recalled William Randolph Hearst claiming that the Arbuckle scandal was more lucrative to his newspaper empire than the sinking of the RMS Lusitania.) Arbuckle’s public profile was now entirely entwined in this sordid tragedy, and with Hollywood scrambling to repair its own image by distancing itself from him, Arbuckle’s only subsequent work would be done behind the camera under the pseudonym William Goodrich. It would be decades until books by David Yallop and Andy Edmonds would promote a counter-myth, attempting to rehabilitate Arbuckle’s image by impugning Virginia Rappe’s. I eagerly await the publication of a new book being written by Joan Myers, who has researched Rappe’s own biography and gone back to original court documents that neither Yallop nor Edmonds accessed. Myers promises to get us closer to understanding the Arbuckle scandal than ever before, but even she says that what exactly happened on the 12th floor of the St. Francis Hotel is “something I don’t know and never will.”
Was a comedy masterpiece lost to cinema history when Leap Year was buried in 1921? No, but the film is well worth watching, especially with an audience primed by a masterfully improvised live score by pianist Judith Rosenberg. Directed by James Cruze (who later made The Covered Wagon and the long-lost satire Hollywood for Paramount) and photographed by Karl Brown (whose memoir Adventures with D.W. Griffith is one of the canonical books about the director), Leap Year is well-produced entertainment that begins rather calmly only to turn frantically funny in its final reels. Arbuckle plays Stanley Piper, a wealthy layabout with a nagging stutter who is constantly getting into girl trouble in defiance of his “grouchy, gouty & girl hating” uncle Jeremiah (Lucien Littlefield). At a Catalina Island resort, he tries to stay out of trouble by offering friendly advice to three women he encounters, but it backfires, as each one believes Stanley’s actually proposing to her. Though the laughs in this section of the film are sparse, the Niles audience reacted uproariously to one particular gag dependent on the position of the camera relative to a golf bag.
The three women follow Stanley to his uncle’s mansion, where the old man is being cared for by a nurse (Mary Thurman) with a bobbed haircut that makes her a dead ringer for Colleen Moore or Louise Brooks circa 1928. Stanley’s heart lies with this nurse, and together they devise a scheme for him to scare off his would-be wives, pancaking his face with sickly makeup as he feigns a series of fits. They fail to foresee that these women’s nurturing (or perhaps gold-digging?) instincts might make a stricken heir an even more attractive husband than a well one. By this point in the film, the audience was laughing almost continuously. Arbuckle’s graceful control of his own body is displayed all the better when his character is forced to give a performance layered atop the actor’s own. Stanley’s self-inflicted pratfalls intended to narrow his suitresses prove that Arbuckle was no less agile than Keaton, Chaplin or Harold Lloyd. He may never have found a feature-length film showcase to match the “big three” silent comics at their best, but we can assume this was only because his opportunities ended the same moment Virginia Rappe’s life did.
Brian Darr is a San Francisco native who works at a library but spends much of his free time watching, researching and writing about film. Since 2005 he has published a blog on local repertory and festival screenings, called Hell On Frisco Bay. He has contributed articles to Senses Of Cinema, GreenCine, and Keyframe, and is a regular writer for the San Francisco Silent Film Festival and the film editor for First Person Magazine. He’s even dabbled in programming 16mm film and video.





Considering Ray's name would be hailed by
On the power of his private screening of They Live by Night,
After the chaos of WWII, a new standard of normality was introduced in America. In Nicholas Ray's perspective, America was a land defined by its own emotional vagrancy, where words like "home" and "family" were becoming more nebulous by definition. The lonely place of Hollywood, the urban jungle of On Dangerous Ground contrasted with the transcendental snow-covered mountains, the deserts of vast, existential dread in Bitter Victor and the lonely roads of The Lusty Men — these were the landscapes where Ray's protagonists found themselves longing for a more gravitationally bound existence.
Having perfected the understanding of reckless teenagers, the ever-growing Ray now focused his gaze on American parents. Although on the other side of the wide generational gap, Bigger Than Life and Rebel are sister films. See how young actor Christopher Olson's red jacket matches James Dean's famous windbreaker? That's not an accident. Much like Samuel Fuller in Shock Corridor, Ray approached all-American family man Ed Avery's drug addiction and illness as a magnifying glass revealing deep cracks in the American dream.
Ray's life was interrupted again, this time by a cancer diagnosis. His final contribution to personal cinema came in the form of a documentary/dramatic narrative hybrid called Lightning Over Water, directed by Ray and 
In an incredibly discomfiting confessional moment, he said that when he fucks Gaga and she comes, she can’t stand to look him in the face because she can’t stand to share an honest moment. Then he and a dance troupe in Calderone chic high-kicked into a jazzed up version of “Yoü And I,” complete with West Side Story-style choreography and a shredding Brian May cameo. When the Queen guitarist ended the song by leaning affectionately against his front man, I couldn’t help but flash back to May’s time with Mr. Freddie Mercury, and sense that a baton was being handed down, as May once sang, “from father to son.”
Understanding the flaws in Gaga’s confessional auto-erotica becomes easier when you A-B it with P!nk’s flawless journey into queered doppelgänger territory in her video for "Sober". Directed by
And so I wonder if the reason for the video’s flaws, such as its uncharacteristically twitchy editing and the sense that Gaga is constantly trying to cut away from things, might be less of a creative crisis and more the manifesting humanity of the artist. It might be that this slip into confessional caused a very sudden, frightening sense of nakedness that almost required the birth of Mr. Calderone. This isn’t Gaga creating abstractions about poker faces, paparazzi or teeth. For the first time, this is about her showing her soft places to millions in something approximating traditional singer-songwriter mode. But this being Gaga, standard definitions always blur and mutate. The video, as dysfunctional to the rest of us as much as it is an art piece, can’t help but work to protect her from real pain, doing so with a wild storm of imagery and other beautiful things. It’s what anyone with a bohemian broken heart does except, when you’re Gaga, you get to do it with a full film, couture, makeup, lighting and CG crew. You get to invent Jo Calderone, who may bust your balls about your intimacy problems, but clearly has your back.
Too often people talk dramatically about game changers and revolutions; rather than functioning as “
Evolution has taken its course and we now find ourselves at a moment in time where rotoscoping manifests itself in performance capture, an adapted technique of which I am an enthusiast, and keen to see evolve further. To date, it’s been most commercially popular in James Cameron’s Avatar, but let’s not overlook the major, trailblazing work in this realm of director
“I’ve just given myself a natural segue to start bashing Zemeckis as a soulless high-tech noodler — a label hung on him by hostile critics who miss the 1980s showman who directed Used Cars and Back to the Future and think he’s lost touch with his artistry, and maybe his soul. I can understand their dissatisfaction — I loved the old Zemeckis, too. But I’m impressed with what Zemeckis has become. The three films he shot in the 3-D motion-capture process — The Polar Express,
Spielberg has described performance capture as being “digital makeup” and I think that’s a useful place to start. We also might look to
For those who might remember the second “generation” of Comics Scene magazine that ran during the early ’90s, there always seemed to be some bit of news and information about an adaptation of the comic Plastic Man that Spielberg was supposed to executive produce. Perhaps now the performance capture tools exist to make such an adaptation possible. It’s heartening to hear Spielberg talking about how his experience of producing Tintin made him think like a painter.
Having found ourselves wandering, then, into the contested realm of discussions about computer animation and its relationship to the process of performance capture, we might also find ourselves in proximity to the well worn trail of discussion about
I’m playing around here a bit, but perhaps a more accurate name for performance capture is ‘performance painted’. Indeed, I have often wondered what a performance capture film could be like if it used digital makeup and costume to achieve the same look of a
Animation historian
In broadening our understanding of the intersection of animation, photography and performance capture, there’s an unsurprisingly thoughtful and energizing discussion of the issue to be found
A little while back when I worked as a lecturer in film, I encouraged students to read even just a little of 
Meanwhile, The Smurfs and Rise of the Planet of the Apes (which is hugely indebted to 1972’s Conquest of the Planet of the Apes) are raking in the bucks at your local multiplex. There was also a recent remake of 1982’s Conan the Barbarian that tanked. On Sept. 16, writer-director Rod Lurie (The Contender) will release his remake of Sam Peckinpah’s 1971 revenge thriller Straw Dogs. Director Tony Scott (Unstoppable) is working on a remake of Peckinpah’s The Wild Bunch. And there’s going to be a new version of The Thin Man with Johnny Depp in the William Powell role, written by David Koepp (Jurassic Park) and directed by Rob Marshall (Chicago). There are new Spider-Man and Superman films coming out, just a few scant years after those properties were already totally remade for the big screen. A long-delayed remake of “Red Dawn” will pit plucky American youth against North Koreans instead of Russians and Cubans. Remakes of Footloose (directed by Craig Brewer of Hustle and Flow) and John Carpenter’s The Thing are scheduled for October. Will the upcoming remake of Dirty Dancing put Baby in a corner?
There are several lines running through Tsui’s oeuvre, including an interest in Chinese history (reflected in Detective Dee’s 7th-century-A.D. setting) and a tendency to create strong female characters (also displayed here), but his interest in special effects connects Detective Dee with the early ’80s films that won the Hong Kong director a cult following in the West. For Zu: Warriors From The Magic Mountain, made in 1983, he brought effects technicians from Hollywood, and the result is a film whose special effects almost overwhelm the narrative. While most American directors try to use special effects seamlessly, Tsui, with his use of devices like optical printers, gave the impression of running wild. I don’t mean that as a criticism; Zu remains an exhilarating blast, one that seems drunk on the possibilities of filmmaking. Twenty-eight years later, the same can be said for Detective Dee.
As Detective Dee begins, a foreign dignitary is visiting the Towering Buddha. After moving an amulet, one of his Chinese hosts suddenly bursts into flame; six other men under the command of Empress Wu (Carina Lau) suffer the same fate. On the eve of her coronation, she seeks the help of Detective Dee (Andy Lau), whom she had previously imprisoned. His investigations turn up a trail of poisoned water, mysterious amulets and venomous beetles, ultimately leading to a plot against the Empress.
Detective Dee combines feminist sympathies with a strain of conservatism. Detective Dee laments Empress Wu’s reliance on torture to gain power, suggesting it as one reason people dislike her. However, he ultimately forgives her use of violence. The film’s rebels offer no legitimate criticism of the Empress, instead referring to her as “the bitch” and acting mostly out of sheer misogyny. Carina Lau’s performance is remarkable, embodying a number of potentially contradictory traits. The Empress seems comfortable with great power and privilege, but at the same time she knows her paranoia is justified by her position, as her power could come crashing down at any moment. For all of her flaws, one leaves Detective Dee with respect for Empress Wu.
Long after his heyday in the ’80s and early ’90s, Tsui’s style, which once seemed so adventurous and untamed, now looks classical compared to the likes of Paul Greengrass (let alone Michael Bay). His fondness for long shots is rare among contemporary action directors, and his skill at balancing set pieces and narrative development has returned since going missing after 1995’s The Blade. The mystery of Detective Dee often feels like an excuse to stage elaborate stunts, as when a seduction attempt turns into an attack by hundreds of arrows. That said, it has its failings as a detective story, as Tsui seems to lose interest in that element of the film halfway through, leaving one to wonder if Lin Qianyu’s source novel is any more satisfying as a mystery.
If anything, this new box set only confirms my opinion that the best DVD package released under the Eclipse label thus far has been their Nikkatsu Noir set, the only one of the Eclipse series not dedicated strictly to a single director. Nikkatsu Noir gave viewers a more comprehensive look at who was making what film at a certain period of time during Japan’s New Wave. To be fair, The Warped Worlds of Koreyoshi Kurahara also provides some great context for Kurahara neophytes (i.e., most everyone, including myself — I had only seen The Warped Ones before digging into this new box set). But after Kurahara’s two 1960 productions, the other featured titles are a little disappointing.
This does not necessarily mean Intimidation is a crude thriller. On the contrary, Kurahara’s films are very sophisticated when it comes to establishing mood through dynamic mise-en-scène. The dialogue-free nightmare sequence where we, as Kurahara’s camera, follow Takita as he robs the bank is a fantastic, gripping set piece. Its atmospheric but meticulous lighting, especially as we’re looking through a door’s rectangular peephole, is worthy of Fritz Lang’s American film noir. The sinuous tracking shots give you the illusion of genuinely looking through the eyes of a frantic robber, even when the camera is poised behind Takita. Kurahara trains his camera on singular objects, like the dial of the safe as Takita opens it, or the “X”-marked handles of the screen door leading to an employee’s office. The scene ends with an extreme close-up of the robber in profile so that you only see his ear and his sweaty cheek. That close-up is astounding for its expressionistic detail, and it’s one of many times you’ll see Kurahara externalize his characters’ inexorable feelings of panic through sweat.
In fact, sweat is the biggest constant in Kurahara’s films. No other film best exemplifies the wonderful things Kurahara can do with perspiration than The Warped Ones. In it, Akira (Tamio Kawachi), a young, animalistic beatnik, runs amuck on an unsuspecting urban populace with several pounds of sweat on his face and a howl on his lips. He doesn’t want sympathy, understanding or analysis; he just wants to have his way all the time. He terrorizes art galleries and gulps down ice cream cones while shucking and jiving to “black music” (jazz, but nothing by any white guys or Japanese imitators). And he also can’t stop bumping into Yuki (Yuko Chishiro), a beautiful young artist whom he can’t help himself from coveting and subsequently raping on a remote beach. The shimmering reflective surfaces of The Warped Ones, especially the white-hot sand dunes during this rape scene, complement the inky shadows of Intimidation quite nicely.
Akira’s story is infinitely more satisfying in The Warped Ones than the way it’s reworked in Black Sun, a sequel/remake of sorts where Akira (still played by Kawachi) runs around with a black G.I. stationed in Japan. The vitality of The Warped Ones relies entirely on the combination of a savagely puerile sense of humor with Kurahara’s consummately refined aesthetic. Without the venom of The Warped Ones or Intimidation, you’re stuck with interesting but stodgy melodramas like the A Face in the Crowd-esque I Hate But Love and Thirst for Love, the latter of which is based on a novel by Yukio Mishima.